The album is alright, but I don't think I'll be able to truly get into it. I'll go into detail since I have a few spare minutes here.
"You Think You Know" is a good example of why I dislike the path David Draiman is heading down as a frontman. This album is actually filled with examples of that. The verses of "You Think You Know" are pretty decent, but really predictable. So, that said, it's all in the delivery...and Draiman just isn't that dynamic or interesting. He goes for extremely rhythmic and pretty much succeeds, but doesn't transcend what he's written, if that makes any sense. There were no "Oh wow" moments in throughout this song. The chorus is by far the worst part, as Draiman just kind of floats along on it....over and over and over.
Instrumentally, this is exactly what you'd expect it to be. It's pretty good, but it's not Disturbed...
I just think David is deteriorating in his abilities with time. I get something of a The Sickness vibe from the verses of "You Think You Know", but that's instantly shattered as it becomes apparent that the bite really isn't there anymore, and in addendum, some bits sound either studio treated or done in different takes to add to the effect. For example: "Get! The! Fuck! Up!" sounds disconnected from its context, in addition to lacking the enunciation to truly bring it out. It's weak. As is Draiman on most of this song, unfortunately.
The album has its triumphs, I have to admit. "Penance" is overwhelmingly the best track, in my opinion. David absolutely utilizes a creepy tone in addition to words like "botticellian" and phrases like "shrouded in evil" to add greatly to it, and it really works here. The bounce of the guitar syncopates spot on with Dave's vocals. The chorus absolutely soars, and I can't help but singing with the melody when it comes along. It feels unexpected and engaging and just amazing, rather than "easy" and predictable like most of the choruses on this album. Then the bridge comes out, and it knows exactly what to do. It doesn't overstay its welcome, but it adds a pleasant bit of spontaneity to the mix by making the song a bit more vocally rhythmic. This track just fires on all cylinders all the way through, and thoroughly impresses me. It's disappointing that it's really the only track that does...
"Vilify" is kind of despised for me at this point. For one thing, now that I have a measuring stick, the verses remind me way too much of "You Think You Know". Way too similar. And they definitely have the same weaknesses. David fails to enunciate, making him hard to understand. His lacks the punctuated power he used to be so good at. And then the chorus... Disappointing. "When you vilify"/"As you vilify"/"When you vilify"/"If you vilify" - why does he need to use this same line so many times in the chorus? In addition, these lines were obviously recorded on separate takes from everything else in the chorus, making it feel choppy and disconnected. The chorus is altogether just too repetitive and unwieldy, almost ungainly. As a small note, the bridge in this song is also pathetic... He rhymes "Inside" with "inside" and "right" with "right". It's....unusual? In a bad way.
"Close My Eyes Forever" just shouldn't have happened, period. I'm not opposed to David and Lzzy doing a piece together (though I do think they are lacking in chemistry a bit...), but this song is legendary. Covering it was a risk that didn't really pay off. It doesn't sound bad necessarily, but I can't help but thinking "Man, Ozzy and Lita did this better before.." at quite a few parts. Instrumentally, the programmed drums take away from the song and nothing really even stands out anyways. Vocally, Draiman sounds clearly a lot weaker than Lzzy (who sounds decent). It kind of unbalances the song. Basically, I don't see why everyone was raving about this one. It's alright, but it's got nothing that really makes me want it rather than the original.
"Out of Line" is actually a pretty cool track. It's plodding, and the vocal melodies are clearly calculated. The rhyme scheme is impressive, very Serj-like. Which is because Serj is in this song. And I like the harmonizations Serj and Dave pull off. It's pretty cool. I'm a bit disappointed that Serj's voice doesn't meld well with Device instrumentally. But I love the message and the vocal lines, otherwise. It's not a "Wow!!" song, but it's pretty damn good anyways.
"Hunted" is pretty cool at first. David's voice has a gravelly feel to it here that melds perfectly with the Device vibe. Instrumentally, the song is brutal. Lyrically, it's nothing impressive. The little bit of brilliance they capture in this song once again lies purely in the chemistry between Draiman and the rest of the band in the verses. And they once again fail to expand well on that idea, which is disappointing. The chorus is disappointing and throwaway. Overall, the song has a shred of brilliance buried in a mass of Meh.
I don't want to comment too much on "Opinion" because I feel it would be ironic to give my opinion on a song titled "Opinion" and because I feel that at this point in the album, they're just kind of repeating themselves. They keep sticking to the same song structure - rhythmic and syncopated verses, and choruses with bigger melodies that usually end up falling flat for some reason. It's quite like Disturbed in that way, except Disturbed is much better at it and even managed to break it up a bit with songs like "Remnants"/"Asylum", "Another Way to Die".
"War of Lies" is very strange and not too memorable at all. Again, same pitfalls they keep falling in.
"Haze" is....different. It's got that low bass buzz to it. I like how Draiman's lower register compliments that. It's a pretty good thing. I also like the guitar tone before and during the chorus. "Inhibitions are left behind" is vividly descriptive to me, for some reason. I do not like M. Shadows. I find him extremely bland and predictable in Avenged Sevenfold, and it's the same thing here. He's got a frail and bland voice. Overall, though, this song is pretty decent. The main thing that carries it, especially in consideration of the rest of the album, is the guitar tone, in my opinion.
"Through it All", thankfully, finally slows down the album's pace. It's been needed. That rhythmic, syncopated verse structure is absent. That's refreshing. Glenn Hughes also brings a modicum and awesome to the closer on this album. His voice compliments the sound well. Naturally. It creates a contrast that's pleasant. And then the track blasts off and picks it up again... finally, some ebb and flow to this album! Pacing... Pretty good song, overall.
There are a few things I want to bring up. I noted that Draiman seems to be falling into patterns that are predictable or "easy" for him. I want to elaborate on that. I have some examples... If I had a nickel for every time Draiman has used "InsaniTAAAAY" of late, I'd be pretty wealthy indeed. On this album alone, he uses it that exact same way twice... First on "Vilify" and then on "Out of Line". I want to note that we know that Draiman is Disturbed and belongs in an Asylum, Believing in The Sickness. And even though that belief is Indestructible, I really wish he would use different descriptors at some point when referring to the state of the world or the state of someone's mind. The fact that he uses it twice the same way here is silly and uninventive. And this isn't the first time he's used it. His overuse of "vilify" in the same-titled song is another example of that.
There's a bigger point here. There's a vibe just dripping everywhere on this album - in the lyrics and the vocal melodies and the vocal rhythm. It all seems so typically David Draiman, doesn't it? I mentioned earlier that the pattern of fast-paced, staccato verses followed by a slower and more melodic chorus repeats itself again and again on this album, to sickening effect. That pattern lies mainly in the vocal line. He uses the same descriptors he's fallen back on for years (words like "InsanitAY") to talk about the same ideas he's discussed for years (fucked up relationships and the state of the world) arranged in a structure he's used for years (fast-paced verse, melodic chorus, etc), except he seems WORSE at it than he was before - less inventive and less engaging. Again, it's a problem that permeates the whole album for me. We've been hearing David talk about messed up relationships and the political state of the world in not so subtle terms since Ten Thousand Fists. It was getting stale on Asylum. By now it's just completely not exciting. I would love it if David applied his voice differently - tried to deliberately be more powerful on his own, rather than layering his vocals so much. Take a risk and don't use the first words that come to his mind (InsaniTAYYY) - try to come up with something more inventive instead. Break the monotony of that badly-executed staccato verse thing he's grown into. It's just disappointing that in many ways, it doesn't seem like he's trying to break ground anymore.
Another thing is that this entire project comes off as kind of pretentious. The "song meaning" videos kind of encompass this idea...does anybody else find those pretentious? They think that David's interpretation of what he wrote will matter to us enough to post those meanings before the album is even out? They're cool to see, sure...but it would also be cool to just get the album and form my own opinion on these songs. The bigger point I'm trying to make here is that this project just kind of seems to take itself too seriously. Those three guys in the video seem stiff and serious while Draiman takes a minute or more to explain in overwhelming detail the rather simple meaning of a rather straightforward song. I just can't see them joking or having too much fun. And that comes through in the music. Nothing about it has much levity. It's all way too superserious in a way. It's kind of sad.
Those are just a few of my initial thoughts on the album. Overall, I'm kind of disappointed. While none of it is by any means bad, it's just not that great. The instrumental aspect takes something of a backseat to The Almighty David, who himself basically flaunts his Achilles Heel all throughout the album, falling into the same patterns and vernacular and even subject matter he usually uses, making this seem like nothing new or exciting - somewhere we've been before. I got no chills throughout this experience. I got a lot of memories of Disturbed. I got a lot of "Oh, that was a pretty cool collaboration" moments. I had no "Oh wow!" moments. As far as flow...the album just kind of rushes through, and doesn't take time to slow down and take stock of itself until the very last song, where that song structure is finally shattered.