I'll be honest, I didn't dig it much...
It gets a 6/10. There are a few reasons for this.
The chief reason among them is David. To me, this song could have benefited from a different perspective. Right now, David is talking as if he's Damien Echol. While there's not anything wrong with this on paper, I just find that style of writing annoying, as when I'm singing along, I feel like I'm singing about someone else's story, and then the lyrics don't seem to come from the heart; they're less personal. I wish David wrote this song with how disgusted he was at the situation in mind, rather than trying to "be" Damien Echols. I had a similar issue with Never Again, honestly. I miss David's old reaction style of writing, and I prefer it over what he did with "3".
That's my main problem with it. David's delivery is pretty perfect for the song (with the chorus melodies aside, which I find unwieldy and not-addictive), and it reminds me of Indestructible as far as some of the instrumental parts go. When I first heard it, that was my reaction; "Man, this sounds like Indestructible!" Then David came in and I heard the Asylum monster in there. So the song's like one big ball of Indestructible and Asylum.
Overall, the song rocks, but not as much as most of Asylum. You know?